On this episode, we delve into one of the weirdest and most brutal crimes of the ’80s…the Chicago Rippers. In a nearly 17-month span beginning in late May 1981, several women disappeared or were found murdered in Chicago and the surrounding suburbs. On Saturday morning, May 15, 1982, real estate agent Donald Stibbe, arrived for […]
On today’s episode, Adam, Caitlin and Kari talk about the famous and mysterious ghost ship the Mary Celeste! The Mary Celeste was a cargo ship traveling from New York City to Genoa, Italy in 1872, carrying industrial alcohol. It was discovered floating, empty of its crew and captain, and with nearly the entire ship […]
Just in time for the week after Thanksgiving, Adam and Kari discuss some of the creepiest (and for some reason mostly unsolved) crimes that happened on Thanksgiving day. Pretty Scary boo!
Her murder is considered the prototype that kicked off the true crime genre. On this episode, we discuss the sad and mysterious death of Mary Cecelia Rodgers, aka the Beautiful Cigar Girl. Oh, and Caitlin is back! Pretty Scary boo!
Boo! Pretty scary, right!? Not as scary as this week’s episode about murders that happened on Halloween night! Check it out! Halloween Night Murders The Trick Or Treat Murder Joan Rabel convinced a random woman named Goldyne Pizer to help her murder this guy, Peter Fabiano, claiming he was “a […]
Howdy folks! This episode of Pretty Scary on the Beverly Hills Supper Club fire features special guests Jon Shefsky and Rich Slaton from the CRiiiME podcast! The Beverly Hills Supper Club Fire The Beverly Hills Supper Club, located in Southgate, Kentucky (a suburb of Cincinnati, Ohio), was a grandly decorated venue, famous in […]
Adam, Caitlin and Kari discuss the NFL’s concussion epidemic and some of its most noteworthy victims. Pretty Scary boo!
Are you familiar with the Rendlesham Forest Incident? It’s a 1980 UFO sighting commonly referred to as “the Roswell of England”. The story is fascinating, and you can hear all about it on this week’s episode of Pretty Scary: Kari couldn’t make it this week, but Adam and Caitlin reluctantly power on nonetheless. So you’re not […]
There’s a new episode of Pretty Scary up now on the subscription site. We highly encourage you to check it out. To get you all excited for it and whatnot, here’s an outtake from the show. In this clip, co-host Caitlin Cutt shares a recording with the power to turn even the darkest of days […]
True crime writer Joan Renner joins Adam, Kari, and Caitlin to discuss one of the most notorious unsolved murders of all-time.